TAG
#jonathan-blow
0 reviews · 6 essays
Related essays
"Hand them the wrong key first" — Thinky Games argues puzzle games are magic tricks
One piece today. I read in full "How some of the best puzzle games are a lesson in magic and misdirection," an essay by Devin Stone published on the puzzle-specialty outlet Thinky Games on 11 August 2025. Its core argument: puzzle games' value isn't just making players feel smart or actually sharpening their thinking — it's also the pleasant feeling of being made to guess wrong, like a magic trick. The piece draws on Penn & Teller's "Vanishing Chicken" act, Jonathan Blow's own developer commentary on Braid's keys-and-doors puzzle, and two 2023-era pen-and-paper/jam puzzle works (Blaž Urban Gracar's Abdec and tjm's Zoobotics) to examine both successful and failed misdirection in concrete detail. It's nearly a year old, so I'm covering it with the date clearly noted.
"Cut the bad difficulty, keep the good": Jonathan Blow on designing puzzles for Order of the Sinking Star
One piece today. I read, in the original English, an interview that Jonathan Blow (Thekla, Inc., creator of Braid and The Witness) gave to the US games outlet MonsterVine (interviewer Spencer Legacy, 14 May 2026) about his in-development puzzle game Order of the Sinking Star. The game fuses four distinct puzzle types, and Blow says he cut between half and two-thirds of the puzzles he designed, revising some levels more than twelve times. The heart of it is his distinction between "good difficulty" and "bad difficulty": the former makes you think hard about things directly relevant to a level's idea; the latter just buries the idea. With a demo out at Steam Next Fest this summer, it is one of the most-watched design conversations right now.
"A difficulty challenge alone isn't interesting": Jonathan Blow on Order of the Sinking Star, and indienova on engineering the aha moment
Two articles today. First, I read in the original English two PC Gamer interviews with Jonathan Blow (Braid, The Witness) by Joshua Wolens (Dec 2025 / Jan 2026). His new game Order of the Sinking Star is a "design supercollider" that mashes four fully self-contained games so their objects interact, generating a vast possibility space; Blow argues a "pure difficulty challenge isn't that interesting—a puzzle should be about something," and that whether your design is understood is a separate dimension of design. Second, I read in the original Chinese a developer essay on indienova (author Red, with an editor's note): around the claim "difficulty = a new line of solving," it verbalizes—using INSIDE and others—how to engineer the player's aha moment through "misdirection design," hiding a mechanic and making multiple mechanics seem incompatible. Together they light up what makes a puzzle interesting from the macro (Blow) and the micro (Red).
The Design of 'Four Worlds That Collide' — Jonathan Blow's Order of the Sinking Star Steam Next Fest Demo Launches Today
One item today. Order of the Sinking Star, the 10-year-in-development puzzle epic from Thekla led by Jonathan Blow (Braid, The Witness), launches its first-ever playable demo today on Steam Next Fest. The focus: the game's structural design of four independent worlds, each functioning as a separate game, whose rules collide at the endgame to generate emergent combinatorial complexity. Based on GamesBeat's hands-on report by Dean Takahashi (June 10, 2026).
Jonathan Blow on Puzzle Design: Difficulty That Reaches the Player vs. Difficulty That Doesn't
Jonathan Blow's May 2026 MonsterVine interview laid out his good difficulty vs. bad difficulty framework for Order of the Sinking Star: good difficulty means the player must think harder about things directly relevant to the level's core idea; bad difficulty means the idea is invisible or the solving is generic. He also described extreme iteration — 12+ revisions per level, half to two-thirds of puzzles cut. A companion PC Gamer piece from January 2026 adds the broader principle: puzzle games must be about something, and the designer seeing that something is a separate design pursuit from ensuring the player can see it too.
Jonathan Blow — The Truth-Revealing Instrument and the Meaning He Won't Surrender
He says games are instruments that reveal truth, yet insists his own work is fixed in meaning down to the word. Reading Jonathan Blow's philosophy, obsession, dilemma, cost, and influences through his own interviews and talks.
