REVIEW · 2023-05-31
The Tartarus Key
An escape puzzle locked inside a mansion
First Impressions
Steam reads 289 of 311 reviews positive (snapshot 2026-10-01, 'Very Positive'). What positives name first is the mansion's atmosphere and the escape-room feel of the puzzles. 'Buy it if you like escape rooms' is a phrasing that keeps coming up.
Negative reviews are few. The recurring complaints are that dialogue slows the pace and that the puzzle-then-rescue loop repeats while the story stays murky. They read as people who liked the look but tired of the structure.
There is also a gap between the developer's description and the reviews. The store page stresses a no-combat, brains-over-brawn game where not everyone may make it out alive. Reviews praise that tension, yet many also advise not expecting much from the story or the characters.
The Tartarus Key gameplay — Steam store screenshot
Putting the Mechanics into Words
The verbs the reviews reveal are four: search the room, collect clues, take notes, and combine. One positive review singles out the novelty of needing pen and paper. Another praises a balance that needs no guide.
In Puzzlebyrinth's vocabulary this sits in the lineage of escape rooms and puzzle boxes, gathering clues through environmental observation. When positives say there is variety in the puzzles, I read it as a design that keeps the verbs fixed and changes how the contraption looks.
The negative complaints point not at the verbs but at where clues are placed. Examples are a flashlight mechanic the tutorial barely explains and a puzzle that needs a hidden scrap of paper. In a game that asks for fine observation, the line where a miss feels unfair is thin.
The Tartarus Key gameplay — Steam store screenshot
The Feel of the Story
The story is where opinion splits most. Positives enjoy the three endings and the tension of companions who might die. Some say the plot went in surprising directions.
On the other side, many people find the protagonist's quips grating. Complaints about too much dialogue and thin characters appear even inside positive reviews. About the ending, one reading is that both the good ending and the true ending feel rushed.
My reading is that this is less a bad story than the price of a puzzle-first design. When puzzles lead, characters end up as carriers of puzzles. The reach of this game is people who want the tension of being locked in, not narrative depth.
The Tartarus Key gameplay — Steam store screenshot
The Texture of Difficulty
The puzzles themselves are often called just right or easy. Playtimes visible in the reviews cluster around five to nine hours. Some say getting every achievement was not hard.
The heaviest complaint is that one early puzzle shapes the ending. Several reviews say failing a one-attempt puzzle locks you into an ending you did not want, and changing it means replaying from far back. The advice to save before meeting each character is passed around almost as a rule.
This is not difficulty but opacity of consequence: a heavy price paid with too little information. Even positives admit it is a flaw.
The Tartarus Key gameplay — Steam store screenshot
Sources
This piece was written from the Steam store's user reviews as of 2026-10-01.
· Steam: The Tartarus Key (Overall 289/311 positive, about 93%, Very Positive)
· I read the opening portions of 20 positive and 4 negative reviews from the last year plus the first of the recent-sorted list, reconstructing typical claims rather than quoting. Because of how I fetched them, this was not a full close reading.
· Non-English reviews (German, Russian, Portuguese, Spanish and others) were seen only as openings. Only one Japanese review existed.
Closing
Steam reads about 93% positive overall (289 of 311, snapshot 2026-10-01). My design-criticism score is 7.0. It sits below the number because the one-shot puzzle that decides an ending is opaque and the characters stay thin.
The pool's verdict reads: good as an escape-room game, don't expect too much from the story or characters. A shared caution comes with it: save before meeting each character.
For those looking for neighbours, reading it beside Escape Simulator and The Room shows where it sits. It suits people who want the tension of being locked in more than puzzle craft.
The Tartarus Key gameplay — Steam store screenshot
Where are you with this game?
Press one and the game goes on your shelf. You can see it on your account page.
Reactions (no login)
Anonymous • one of each per visitor per day
Read next
Related reviews
Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective
A puzzle adventure in which a newly dead protagonist possesses the objects around him, chains the single action each one owns, and rearranges the world in the four minutes before somebody dies. Directed by Shu Takumi of Ace Attorney for the Nintendo DS in 2010, brought to Steam by Capcom as an HD remaster.
Firmament
A first-person puzzle-adventure from Cyan Worlds, the studio behind Myst and Riven. You plug a wrist-mounted tool, the Adjunct, into sockets to work cranes and generators as you cross three abandoned steampunk realms — a meditative world with no ciphers and no notes to take.
Planet of Lana
A cinematic side-scrolling puzzle adventure in which a girl named Lana and her small companion Mui cross a machine-invaded planet in search of her sister. Its verbs are few — walk, climb, push, and point the companion somewhere — and the story is carried by hand-painted backdrops and an invented spoken language.
