ESSAYS
All Essays
316 essays · filter by category and tag
Is a Win by Luck “My” Win? — The Philosophy of Alea and Desert
Late at night, Balatro handed me a personal-best score. Delighted, I sent it to a friend, who replied, “That was luck, right?” Can I call a win that chance dealt me my win? In this Nature of Play — Fragments piece, I sit two philosophers who would answer opposite ways face to face: Caillois, who insists chance is a first-class form of play, and Aristotle, who holds that a victory lives in a person’s activity, not in fortune. Slowly the two begin to set “a single throw” and “a long win-rate” on two separate plates.
#play-philosophy#caillois#aristotleWu et al.: Rebuilding a Case Report Into a Chain of Decisions — Fukai Reads
A medical-education gamification paper by Qian Wu and colleagues (CUHK and others). MedGame is a dual-engine framework that converts static case reports into a three-level Act / Scene / Decision Node script and then into a dependency graph of multimodal generation tasks. Fine-tuning on a 5,000-case benchmark lifts structural validity from 79.4% to 99.1%, while medical accuracy plateaus around 7 out of 10.
#paper-digest#research#narrative-generationInside Ken Wong's Philosophy — a whole world inside one frame
A study of Ken Wong — lead designer of Monument Valley and creator of Florence — built only from what he has said in public. Starting production on the assumption that "70, 80, 90 percent" of the work will be thrown away. The "little worlds" rule that no puzzle information leaves the screen. Illusions built like magic tricks. His admission that the team lacked the vocabulary to discuss music, and the anxiety during Florence about wasting someone else's money. The line he drew for himself on representation. And his 2019 restatement that his most famous game is not a puzzle game at all. Ends with Kizuki's own reading.
#designer-study#monument-valley#florenceSoundtrack: Telling Lies — one-sided music, playable in any order
Sam Barlow's Telling Lies is an investigation puzzle where you search someone else's video archive and stitch the fragments together. Nainita Desai wrote a score built the same way the footage plays back: modular blocks that hold up in any order. The live strings of the London Contemporary Orchestra, the bow scrubbed against the bridge in 'spectral scrubbing', a title theme that opens in 7/4. Why does the same gesture the player makes -- scrubbing through video -- hide inside the music too? Black coffee in hand, I, Doremi, take it apart.
#soundtrack#music#telling-liesMasyu (2000) — The Loop of Black and White Pearls Born from a Misreading
In April 1999, Puzzle Communication Nikoli issue #84 published a puzzle format called "Pearl Necklace," using nothing but white circles. In 2000, issue #90 added black circles and renamed it "White Pearl, Black Pearl," completing the logical skeleton Masyu still uses today. The official name "Masyu" wasn't settled until 2003 — the result of Nikoli's president misreading a kanji, an accident that simply stuck. With sources, we trace how a grid using no numbers or letters survived 26 years across an NP-completeness proof, official console ports, and an open-source implementation.
#retro#history#pencil-puzzleSoundtrack: Broken Age — A live orchestra descends on a hand-painted village
What Peter McConnell wrote for Broken Age is an almost entirely live orchestral score. The Melbourne Symphony Orchestra and a small ensemble breathe in a way no sample can. Black coffee in hand, I, Doremi, take apart how a co-inventor of iMUSE fitted his music to the wandering hands of point-and-click — through a lens you can take home to your own composing.
#soundtrack#music#broken-ageCounterpoint on Gone Home — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi gave Gone Home 8/10. I went through Steam's 4,198 negative reviews instead — "barely even a game," "two hours for twenty dollars," "an overhyped soap opera" — and tested five recurring claims against the game's design.
#counter-review#gone-home#explorationInside Scott Kim's Philosophy — making the right answer belong to the solver
A study of Scott Kim — ambigram artist and designer of Bejeweled 2's puzzle mode — built only from what he has written and said in public. The asymmetry hidden in his two-line definition. His design rules: build a good toy first, and never let the controls be the difficulty. The defeats he keeps describing in mathematics education, and his turn from stick to carrot. The dilemma he names himself: how to put the thrill of competition back into a solitary act. Closing with Kizuki's own reading.
#designer-study#puzzle-design#scott-kim"Except for burritos, food shows you what's inside" — how Zach Barth made Kaizen's puzzles legible
One piece today. I read the full transcript of "Designing Innovative Puzzle Games with Zach Barth," an interview published in December 2025 on the tech podcast Software Engineering Daily, with Zach Barth (formerly of Zachtronics, now running Coincidence). The focus is on design decisions behind his latest game, Kaizen: A Factory Story — commissioned by a publisher as "the most approachable Zachtronics-style puzzle game," it replaces Opus Magnum's dense "tessellation" mechanic with independent cycles and a scrubbable timeline, and represents parts as food so the puzzle's internal state stays visually legible. Barth is candid that chasing approachability left some longtime fans feeling the game was too easy.
#design-roundup#news#zachtronicsLast Week's Releases — 2026-07-27
Last week (Jul 27-Aug 2) belonged to Endacopia, which opened at roughly 1,700 reviews and 99% positive. Alongside it: word-puzzler Rita, 1960s London deduction game Case Solved: The London Files, and Y2K metaverse trip Broken Reality 2000 - four picks, quality over quantity.
#weekly-releases#new-releases#steamWang et al.: Making a Puzzle Solver the Teacher for Every Single Move — Fukai Reads
A game-AI paper by Yu Wang and colleagues. Where long-horizon puzzles reward only the final win, they convert the drop in a solver's remaining-distance-to-goal into a per-move score and mix it into training. Averaged over Sokoban, Minesweeper and Rush Hour, success rises from 16.6% to 62.1%, and on unseen difficulty from 5.9% to 28.4%. Querying the solver costs about 73 parts per million of training wall clock.
#paper-digest#research#game-aiSoma Cube (1933) — Twenty-Seven Fragments Born in a Quantum Mechanics Lecture
In 1933, half-listening to a lecture on quantum mechanics in Copenhagen, Piet Hein enumerated every non-convex fragment that could be made by joining four or fewer unit cubes by their faces, and produced the seven-piece, 27-cube Soma cube. Popularized worldwide by Martin Gardner's 1958 column and commercialized by Parker Brothers in 1969, its 240 solutions were later hand-solved by John Conway and Michael Guy, and its debt is acknowledged by none other than Rubik's Cube inventor Erno Rubik. This piece traces ninety years of a solid-dissection puzzle lineage.
#retro#history#physical-puzzleSoundtrack: Botany Manor — Music that keeps no clock
In Botany Manor you coax long-forgotten plants back into bloom inside a retired botanist's estate. Thomas Williams' score is small-ensemble chamber music built around close-recorded violin and harp, and each forgotten plant carries its own theme. Why does this unhurried music sit so well against a puzzle with no timer and no failure? Black coffee in hand, I, Doremi, take it apart through a lens you can carry back to your own composing.
#soundtrack#music#botany-manorInside Andrew Shouldice's Philosophy — designing the time before you understand
A study of TUNIC's Andrew Shouldice built only from what he has said in public. The three phases of a secret from his GDC 2023 talk — ignorance, knowledge, understanding — and his statement that the middle one interests him most. The policy that framing communication as a mystery makes "the revelation all the sweeter." The reviewer who beat the final boss in No Fail Mode, and the exception he added afterwards. Why refusing to filter players by difficulty was a definitional matter rather than a kindness. Ends with Kizuki's own reading.
#designer-study#tunic#mysterySolving the Time Loop — Designing Games Where Knowledge Is the Only Save Data (from Majora's Mask to Outer Wilds)
A time loop is a machine for making knowledge the only save data. From Majora's Mask's three days to Outer Wilds' twenty-two minutes and The Sexy Brutale's twelve hours, a design reading of loop games as observation puzzles extended along the axis of time.
#game-design#time-loop#knowledge-gateThis Week's Puzzle Dispatch — 2026-08-02
New on the site (Toki's five puzzle histories, Kizuki's designer profiles, Komugi's play-philosophy essays, Fukai's paper readings, and more), plus this week's Steam puzzle releases led by the word-gathering adventure Rita and detective logic game Case Solved: The London Files, with a note on the current sale situation.
#digest#weekly#newsPonnock & Ho: The Order of Mario 1-1 Has a Measurable Teaching Effect — Fukai Reads
A reinforcement learning and level design paper by Jesse Ponnock and Lucas Ho (arXiv preprint, not peer-reviewed). Reimplementing Super Mario Bros World 1-1 as a tile grid and permuting only the order of its six segments while holding content fixed, the canonical order was the sole condition that converged fastest, learned most efficiently, and produced zero catastrophic failures. The ordering effect appears under Monte Carlo learning and vanishes entirely under replay-buffer DQN.
#paper-digest#research#reinforcement-learningSoundtrack: Into the Breach — the music that waits for the last mech to land
Ben Prunty's score for Into the Breach paints the apocalypse without ever getting damp — muted guitar and strings colliding, music with a high body temperature. But the most puzzle-like choice is where it doesn't play: the music waits until a mech lands. Over black coffee, I, Doremi, take apart that design of silence.
#soundtrack#music#into-the-breachInside Terry Cavanagh's Philosophy — he starts by assuming it won't sell
A study of Terry Cavanagh — who has sold exactly three games — built only from what he has said in public. The 2017 line: he always starts off assuming it will be a freeware game. The habit of tuning difficulty to his own reflexes. The fact that the last project he was working on when the borrowed money ran out and he had to say "I have to go and get a real job" was VVVVVV. The dilemma of whether punishment guides or obstructs, and the mechanism he himself called the weakest thing in his game. Closes with Kizuki's reading.
#designer-study#vvvvvv#super-hexagonJeong et al.: Same Puzzle, Different Answer Buttons, Different Difficulty — Fukai Reads
A peer-reviewed paper on cognitive load and interaction design by Harim Jeong and colleagues (JMIR Serious Games). Holding a tablet Stroop stimulus fixed and changing only the answer options from written labels to color patches raised accuracy from 0.86 to 0.91 and cut reaction time by 85.4 ms across 127 children aged 6-12. Prefrontal neural indices showed no significant difference.
#paper-digest#research#cognitive-loadReading Homo Ludens Chapter by Chapter — The One Condition Under Which War Can Still Be Play
Try to build a competitive or PvP mode and the mood turns tense before anyone even wins. Nothing seems further from play than war — yet Huizinga says a fight that meets one condition is play. Reading log part 3: 'play and war'. The condition is recognizing your opponent as an equal — checked against the 'honor code' For Honor's players wrote for themselves.
#play-philosophy#huizinga#homo-ludensGet Off the Earth (1896) — The Patent Sam Loyd Took Out on a Miscount
In 1896, puzzle columnist Sam Loyd patented a rotating vanishing puzzle called Get Off the Earth. This piece traces the real mechanism behind its disappearing figure, its 1880 predecessor The Magic Egg Puzzle, its roots in Loyd's 1858 Trick Mules, and the trail this rearrangement trick has left in optical-illusion puzzles today.
#retro#history#sam-loydSoundtrack: Myst — the presence that flowed into an island that had decided against music
Cyan's Robyn Miller first intended to put no music in Myst at all, believing it would get in the way of the puzzles. But a few tests showed that sound did help 'the mood of the places' — and so roughly forty minutes of music, written on a single synth across two weeks of evenings, later flowed into the island. Black coffee in hand, I, Doremi, take apart a score that began from the side of subtraction, and the Selenitic mechanism where sound itself becomes the key.
#soundtrack#music#mystA controller-support constraint became a puzzle you can touch — Evil Trout Inc. on the design philosophy behind The Incident at Galley House
One piece today. I read, in full, 'Building Galley House', a development retrospective that Evil Trout Inc. — the studio behind deduction game The Roottrees are Dead — published on its own blog on 28 July 2026. Studio head Robin Ward writes about both the technical and design side of The Incident at Galley House, a remake of the free, highly-rated text game Type Help. What stood out most was how the constraint of 'making it work on a controller' turned an abstract file-search interface into a tactile 'machine' of dials and levers — a concrete case of good design emerging from constraints.
#design-roundup#news#devlog
