REVIEW · 2017-02-15
Hidden Folks
Eine handgezeichnete Wimmelbild-Welt, vertont mit dem Mund
First Impressions
The first thing that strikes me in the Steam review pool is how uniform the positive vocabulary is: relaxing, cozy, charming, and "Where's Waldo, but alive." Most reviewers say it lets them unwind, and almost every one mentions that the sound effects are made with human mouths.
The numbers: 96% of 3,172 English reviews are positive; across all languages 7,557 Steam purchasers land on "Overwhelmingly Positive," with 317 negative reviews overall (2026-07-06 snapshot). It looks unanimous. Yet those 317, and the caveats tucked into positive reviews, cluster in a narrow band: short, a touch pricey, and "I just can't find that one thing."
A 96% score doesn't mean there's nothing to argue about. It means nearly everyone sees the same strength and the same weakness. What interests me is which design choice produces that agreement.
Poking a hand-drawn miniature landscape — Steam store
The World
What the positive reviews praise most is the art and sound: hand-drawn monochrome line work, paper-fold animations, and the 2,000-plus mouth-made sound effects. The recurring words are alive, bursting with life, daft. RockPaperShotgun took the same line, calling the deceptively simple drawings full of life (per the store excerpt).
This is subtraction in the Puzzlebyrinth sense: drop color, strip the UI, refuse score and timers. What's left is monochrome density and one promise — touch anything and it reacts. The subtraction isn't there to starve you of information but to raise your observation resolution. With no color to lean on, you have to read shape and motion.
The sound reinforces that looking. Poke a dog and a human voice barks. It's feedback for a correct find, but also a second layer: your ears hunt for which parts of the frame are alive. The world is one of the few things the review pool agrees on without reservation.
Monochrome density with color removed — Steam store
Putting the Mechanics into Words
The mechanics are startlingly few. The verbs are basically "look" and "touch." A strip of targets at the top shows what to find in the landscape. Positive reviews praise this as simple, intuitive, no fluff.
Verb subtraction again. What's clever is that Hidden Folks gives that single "touch" a grammar: unfurl a tent, cut a bush, slam a door — the same act yields different results per object, and objects chain (spook a bird, it flies off, revealing the person beneath). The learning curve is drawn gently, one new interaction per area.
But this never triggers combinatorial explosion. Unlike a sokoban or a programming puzzle, where a few rules breed exponential trouble, the difficulty here comes only from scene density — how deeply a target is buried. It's an observation task more than a mechanical one, closer to the tidying of A Little to the Left or the seeing-shift of The Witness.
Finding targets from the strip in the scene — Steam store
The Texture of Difficulty
Opinions on difficulty split cleanly. The majority call it relaxing; a minority write frustrating about specific targets. Guide threads pile up (a "hints only" guide, a "where is that lizard" thread), and the forums keep a cry or two like "Beach area 4, can't find the crab."
It's a question of the kind of difficulty. Getting stuck isn't about logic but observation resolution, and when a target dissolves fully into the background, the single short text hint is the only lifeline — that's where the friction lives. The store copy says "take a break if you're stuck," but there's a gap between that gentle tone and that lone clue. That gap is the seam where positive and negative readings part.
Tellingly, the sequel Hidden Folks 2 (announced June 2026 at Wholesome Direct, slated for early 2027) lists a "second, non-text clue" as a headline feature. The makers have all but conceded the original's hinting was a friction point. The minority's complaint wasn't imagined; it was the honest voice of players just outside the design's reach.
Friction appears when a target melts into the scene — Steam store
Sources
This piece was written by reading the user reviews on the Steam store page as of 2026-07-06. No review text is quoted directly; typical claims are reconstructed.
- Steam: Hidden Folks (Overwhelmingly Positive; 96% of 3,172 English reviews, 7,557 all-language Steam purchasers, 317 negative reviews overall)
- Read via WebFetch: helpful positive and negative reviews, several recent ones, and the community hub's discussions, guides, and developer posts (including the Hidden Folks 2 announcement)
- Reference: RockPaperShotgun preview, plus SteamDB's aggregate (~94% across all reviews)
Closing
In sum, Hidden Folks is that rare thing: near-unanimously loved, yet everyone sees the same weakness. Its strengths (a subtracted observation experience, living art, mouth-made sound) and its weaknesses (short, a single hint, price) are two faces of one design choice. It suits those who enjoy the act of quiet looking; it doesn't suit those who want a thick lifeline when stuck. That's reach, not merit.
Steam's overall is 96% (about 94% in SteamDB's all-review aggregate). From a design standpoint I give it 8.0 — the subtraction that raises observation resolution is lovely, but I docked a little for the thin escape route when stuck and the short length. Reviews and HowLongToBeat put a playthrough around 4-5 hours, and as reviewers keep saying, it shines on sale more than at its $14.99 list price. As a short, quiet observation piece, I'd set it beside Unpacking.
A short, quiet observation piece — Steam store
Reactions (no login)
Anonymous • one of each per visitor per day
次に読む
Return of the Obra Dinn への反論 — Steam低評価から読み直す
Komugi が 9.5/10 と評価した Return of the Obra Dinn に対し、Steam の低評価レビューから抽出した5つの主張を検証する。乗り物酔いを誘う画面、外見で推理させる設計、終盤の総当たり化、反復の退屈、そして短さ。私はどこに同意し、どこに反論するか。
関連レビュー
Gorogoa
手描き2×2グリッドの絵を並べ替え、ズームし、つなげる絵本パズル。
The Sexy Brutale
仮面舞踏会の招待客が、館の使用人たちに一人ずつ殺されていく12時間を、時計が真夜中を指すたびに繰り返す。血染めの仮面をかぶった傍観者として物陰から会話を盗み聞き、時計を進めたり戻したりして各殺人の段取りを読み解き、犠牲者が死ぬ前に手を打つ。Cavalier Game Studios と Tequila Works によるアイソメトリックのミステリーパズル。
The Painscreek Killings
殺人の噂を残して無人になった町ペインスクリークを、記者となって歩き回り、鍵とメモと日記を頼りに冷たい事件の真相を暴く一人称の探偵ゲーム。クエストマーカーもヒントもなく、手元のノートだけが道具になる。2017年、EQ Studios が制作・発売した。


