SERIES
対抗レビュー
全27期 · 最新 2026-10-05
名作の Steam 低評価レビューには、称賛だけでは見えない設計の弱点が書かれている。Mayoi が毎回1作品を取り上げ、その批判が正当かどうかを実際に遊んで検証する。
连载一览
- 第27期对 Rusty Lake Hotel 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评重新解读2026-10-05
针对 Komugi 评为 7.2/10 的《Rusty Lake Hotel》，检验从 Steam 差评中提炼出的三点主张（存档与重来的不友好、谜题的单调、对于对客人下手这一情节的抵触）。我同意哪些，反对哪些。
- 第26期Counterpoint on GNOSIA — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-28
Komugi rated GNOSIA 8.2/10. I test five claims drawn from its Steam negative reviews — a luck-driven deduction layer, opaque unlock conditions that demand dozens of loops, a grindy wait for a rare late-game skill, recycled dialogue, and missing quality-of-life features — against her review, and say where I agree and where I don't.
- 第25期Counterpoint on Botanicula — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-24
Komugi rated Botanicula 7.8/10. I test five claims drawn from its Steam negative reviews (4.7% of the total) — shallow puzzles, tedious repetition, a short runtime priced too high, absent story, and unclear interactions.
- 第24期Counterpoint on SUPERHOT — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-21
Komugi rated SUPERHOT 8.2/10. I test five claims drawn from its Steam negative reviews — a length-versus-price mismatch, burnout past the first hour, rough controls, resistance to its tone and story, and a steep, badly-taught difficulty curve — against her review, and say where I agree and where I don't.
- 第23期Counterpoint on Thomas Was Alone — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-17
Komugi rated Thomas Was Alone 7.2/10. I test five claims drawn from its Steam negative reviews — repetitive busywork, rough controls, an overbearing narrator, technical neglect like broken achievements, and a length-versus-price mismatch — against her review, and say where I agree and where I don't.
- 第22期Counterpoint on Human Fall Flat — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-10
Komugi rated Human Fall Flat 7.0/10. I read Steam's negative reviews and examined five claims: the dropped Linux support, solo-play tedium, control frustration, camera-induced motion sickness, and how quickly the novelty fades. Where I agree, where I push back.
- 第21期Counterpoint on Untitled Goose Game — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-09-03
Komugi rated Untitled Goose Game 7.5/10. I read Steam's negative reviews and examined five claims: price and length, too few verbs, controls, hype skepticism, and co-op friction. Where I agree, where I push back.
- 第20期Counterpoint on Maquette — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-08-27
Komugi rated Maquette 7.0/10. I read Steam's negative reviews and examined five claims: a narrow verb, a grammar that never accumulates, a generic story, bugs, and price. Where I agree, where I push back.
- 第19期Counterpoint on Firmament — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-08-24
Komugi rated Firmament 6.5/10. I read Steam's negative reviews and examined five claims: tedious puzzles, a thin story, bugs and price, and a broken VR promise. Where I agree, where I push back.
- 第18期对 Papers, Please 的反驳——从 Steam 差评重新解读2026-08-20
针对 Komugi 给出 9/10 评分的 Papers, Please，本文检验从 Steam 差评(约占总数3%)中提炼出的5个主张：重复性、节奏、政治信息的浮浅、动词过少、重玩价值。我在哪些地方赞同，又在哪些地方反驳？
- 第17期对 Return to Monkey Island 的反驳——从 Steam 差评重新解读2026-08-17
针对 Komugi 给出 8.4/10 评分的 Return to Monkey Island，本文检验从 Steam 差评中提炼出的 5 个主张(美术风格、难度下降、提示设计、结局、节奏)。我在哪些地方赞同，又在哪些地方反驳？
- 第16期Counterpoint on Gone Home — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-08-03
Komugi gave Gone Home 8/10. I went through Steam's 4,198 negative reviews instead — "barely even a game," "two hours for twenty dollars," "an overhyped soap opera" — and tested five recurring claims against the game's design.
- 第15期Counterpoint on ANIMAL WELL — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-07-27
Against Komugi's 8.7/10 for ANIMAL WELL, I examine five claims drawn from the negative Steam reviews — retry cost, the refusal to guide, the absence of story and music, "it's actually a platformer," and a deepest layer premised on collective intelligence. I agree with two of them and push back on the other three.
- 第14期Counterpoint on Chants of Sennaar — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-07-23
Komugi rated Chants of Sennaar 8.5/10. I read the negative Steam reviews and examined three families of complaints: genre detours, map-less traversal, and a rushed final act at a full price. Where I agree, and where I push back.
- 第13期对《Antichamber》的反驳 — 从 Steam 低评价重新解读2026-07-20
Komugi 给《Antichamber》打了 8.5/10 分，我从 Steam 低评价中提取出五个主张——信息隐瞒、试错、逆向难度曲线、后半段失速、视觉负担——逐一检验。我在哪里认同，在哪里反驳。
- 第12期Counterpoint on Superliminal — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-07-13
Against Komugi's 7.5/10 for Superliminal, I examine five claims drawn from the negative Steam reviews — length versus price, shallow puzzles, a second half that turns into a walking simulator, motion sickness, and an unearned ending speech. I agree with the sag in the back half and the sermonizing finale, and push back on the verdict that short automatically means bad value.
- 第11期Counterpoint on Return of the Obra Dinn — Reading Through the Negative Reviews2026-07-06
Komugi rated Return of the Obra Dinn 9.5/10. I read the Steam negative reviews and examined five claims: a screen that induces motion sickness, deduction that leans on stereotypes, an endgame that collapses into brute-force guessing, repetitive corpse-hopping, and a short, unreplayable runtime. Where I agree, where I push back.
- 第10期对TUNIC的反驳 —— 从Steam差评中重读2026-06-29
针对Komugi给出8.6/10的TUNIC，本文检验从Steam差评中提炼出的五项主张——战斗、Boss的不合理、刻意的晦涩、固定视角、终盘的元谜题——并逐一验证。我认同其中一项，对其余几项提出反驳。
- 第9期对 Gorogoa 的反驳——从 Steam 低评价重新解读2026-06-25
对于 Komugi 给出 9.0/10 的 Gorogoa，本文从 Steam 低评价中提炼出五个主张加以检验。过短、定价偏高、难度太低、反过来又有不讲道理的穷举搜索、以及故事不够明确。我在哪里赞同、在哪里反驳。
- 第8期对 Storyteller 的反论——从 Steam 低评价重新解读2026-06-22
针对 Komugi 评出 7.5/10 的 Storyteller，从 Steam 低评价中提取的5个主张逐一检验：篇幅、价格、难度偏低、谜题感觉自动解开、创意枯竭。我在哪里认同，在哪里反驳。
- 第7期对 Blue Prince 的反论——从 Steam 低评价重新解读2026-06-18
针对 Komugi 评为9.5/10的 Blue Prince，从 Steam 及社区低评价中提取的主张——随机数阻断进行、两层游戏不协调、中盘单调——逐一检验。我认同随机数的「守门化」，但对「这不是谜题游戏」的断言提出反驳。
- 第6期对 Lorelei and the Laser Eyes 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评里重读2026-06-15
面对 Komugi 给到 9.0/10 的 Lorelei and the Laser Eyes,本文从 Steam 差评中抽取四种主张并加以检验:单键操作、永远不知道解法在哪、密码锁的单调,以及毫无预警的闪烁强光。我同意哪些,反对哪些。
- 第5期对 Outer Wilds 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评里重读2026-06-11
面对 Komugi 给到 9.5/10 的 Outer Wilds,本文从 Steam 差评中抽取四种主张并加以检验:不尊重玩家时间的循环、埋在文本里的故事、痛苦的飞船操作、未被告知的恐怖要素。我同意哪些,反对哪些。
- 第4期对 Stephen's Sausage Roll 的反驳 — 从 Steam 低评价重新解读2026-06-08
针对 Komugi 评出 9/10 的 Stephen's Sausage Roll,从 Steam 低评价中提取的5条主张逐一检验。理不尽的难度、操作的痛苦、缺乏进步感、价格与外观、穷举感。我在哪里同意,在哪里反驳。
- 第3期对 The Witness 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评里重读2026-06-01
面对 Komugi 给到 9.0/10 的 The Witness,本文检验 Steam 与评测媒体反复出现的 5 种差评模式——哲学的做作、操作的单调、终盘的不讲理、移动的烦躁、对色觉/听觉的无视。我同意哪些,反对哪些。
- 第2期对 Baba Is You 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评里重读2026-05-28
面对 Komugi 给到 9.5/10 的 Baba Is You,本文检验 Steam 与各家评测站反复出现的 5 种差评模式——难度的墙、单解的强加、变量的泛滥、挫败感主导、难度波动。我同意哪些,反对哪些。
- 第1期对 COCOON 的反论 — 从 Steam 差评里重读2026-05-26
面对 Komugi 给到 9/10 的 COCOON,本文从 Steam 差评中抽取四种主张并加以检验: 体量短、定价、难度的缺位、叙事的稀薄。我同意哪些,反对哪些。