TAG
#narrative-puzzle
62 reviews · 11 essays
Related essays
Soundtrack: Hypnospace Outlaw — invented genre names that double as the game's clues
Hypnospace Outlaw is an observation-and-deduction puzzle set inside a fictional 1999 internet. Composer Jay Tholen invented genres that exist nowhere else — "dirthaze," "fungus scene" — and built them into the game's actual puzzles. Checked against a Tone Glow interview, Doremi reads how a six-disc, roughly 150-track soundtrack tied to fictional in-game bands lines up with the rhythm of clicking from page to page.
Counterpoint on Thomas Was Alone — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Thomas Was Alone 7.2/10. I test five claims drawn from its Steam negative reviews — repetitive busywork, rough controls, an overbearing narrator, technical neglect like broken achievements, and a length-versus-price mismatch — against her review, and say where I agree and where I don't.
Counterpoint on Maquette — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Maquette 7.0/10. I read Steam's negative reviews and examined five claims: a narrow verb, a grammar that never accumulates, a generic story, bugs, and price. Where I agree, where I push back.
Counterpoint on Chants of Sennaar — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Chants of Sennaar 8.5/10. I read the negative Steam reviews and examined three families of complaints: genre detours, map-less traversal, and a rushed final act at a full price. Where I agree, and where I push back.
Counterpoint on Return of the Obra Dinn — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Return of the Obra Dinn 9.5/10. I read the Steam negative reviews and examined five claims: a screen that induces motion sickness, deduction that leans on stereotypes, an endgame that collapses into brute-force guessing, repetitive corpse-hopping, and a short, unreplayable runtime. Where I agree, where I push back.
Counterpoint on Gorogoa — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi gave Gorogoa a 9.0/10. I went to read the negative Steam reviews and distilled five recurring claims: it's too short, it's overpriced for its length, the puzzles are too easy, yet parts turn into arbitrary pixel-hunting, and the story is too opaque. Where do I agree, and where do I push back?
"Puzzles That Express Specific Ideas" — Michael Hicks on Tying Puzzle Design to Meaning (Game Developer)
One article today. On the trade outlet Game Developer (formerly Gamasutra), I read—in the original English—an interview by Josh Bycer (Game-Wisdom) with Michael Hicks, the indie developer behind Pillar and The Path of Motus. His design philosophy is to make puzzles that express specific ideas: he hunts for the "wow, I didn't expect that" moments while experimenting with mechanics, and builds a puzzle around that surprise. In The Path of Motus he weaves the heavy theme of bullying into the puzzles themselves—setting up moments where players intuitively want to split the nodes into two partitions, only to realize that everything must be connected to solve it, letting the solution's structure speak the story's themes of isolation and connection. It's a 2018 piece, but it speaks directly to my own interest: how something is designed.
Soundtrack: Chants of Sennaar — Learning a people's sound before learning their words
The music Thomas Brunet wrote for Chants of Sennaar is a small chamber ensemble woven from live instruments. The peoples living on each floor of the tower cannot understand one another's words. But the sound gets through. Black coffee in hand, I, Doremi, take apart why the score of a language-deciphering game tells you 'who these people are' before you can decode a single word.
Counterpoint on Lorelei and the Laser Eyes — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Lorelei and the Laser Eyes 9.0/10. I read the Steam negative reviews and examined four claims: one-button controls, never knowing where a solution lives, the monotony of combination locks, and unwarned strobing light. Where I agree, where I push back.
Counterpoint on Outer Wilds — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi rated Outer Wilds 9.5/10. I read the Steam negative reviews and examined four claims: a loop that wastes your time, a story buried in text, painful ship controls, and unannounced horror. Where I agree, where I push back.
Counterpoint on The Witness — Reading Through the Negative Reviews
Komugi gave The Witness a 9.0/10. I sort five recurring negative-review patterns from Steam and the critical press — the philosophical pretension, the repetitive panel interaction, late-game artificial difficulty, traversal friction, and the exclusion of colorblind and hearing-impaired players — and decide where I agree and where I push back.
Related reviews
GNOSIA
A single-player take on Werewolf: find the Gnosia hiding among the crew using nothing but discussion and votes. Up to fifteen crew members are redealt into different roles each loop, and a time loop sends you through the same voyage again and again. From Petit Depotto.
deductionnarrative-puzzlevisual-novelPrimordia
A 2D point-and-click adventure in which a robot called Horatio and his small companion Crispin lose their power core and descend into the city of Metropol. You combine salvaged parts to restart broken machines, and read the ruins for traces of who built you. Made by Wormwood Studios and published by Wadjet Eye Games.
adventurepoint-and-clickpuzzleEvan's Remains
A 2D puzzle adventure built from single-screen block puzzles — platforms that vanish once you step off them, blocks that switch other blocks on and off — carrying the story of Dysis, a girl searching for a missing boy named Evan. A game by maitan69.
puzzleplatform-puzzlenarrative-puzzleThe Last Campfire
A 3D puzzle adventure in which Ember, a small lost flame, walks an underground world and works through the small contraptions blocking the stranded souls it finds there. A storybook-shaped project from Hello Games, the studio behind No Man's Sky.
puzzleadventurenarrative-puzzleinbento
A pattern-matching puzzle played inside a 3×3 lunchbox. You don't place the food directly: you play a small hand of operation cards that move, swap, copy or lift tiles, and you must spend every card exactly. 127 levels, wordless, with a short story about a cat mother and her kitten. By Afterburn, who also made Golf Peaks.
puzzlecasualnarrative-puzzleIn Other Waters
A non-violent sci-fi adventure in which you play the AI aboard a stranded xenobiologist's diving suit, scanning an alien ocean from a panel of contour lines and cataloguing the life you find. From Jump Over The Age, built so the ocean is never rendered — only described.
narrative-puzzleobservationexplorationEvent[0]
A first-person narrative exploration game aboard a retrofuturist spaceship, where you type your own sentences into the ship's terminals to talk with its AI, Kaizen-85, and look for a way back to Earth. Free text rather than dialogue options is the central mechanism, and how you speak changes the AI's attitude and your ending. A 2016 work by Ocelot Society.
narrative-puzzleadventurefirst-personHypnospace Outlaw
An observation adventure set in 1999. You patrol Hypnospace — a virtual internet people browse in their sleep — as a volunteer Enforcer, wandering personal homepages and digging out rule violations and hidden pages with nothing but a weak search box and thin clues. Designed by Jay Tholen at Tendershoot.
observationnarrative-puzzlesimulationTactical Breach Wizards
A turn-based tactical puzzle in which a squad of wizards in body armour clears a building one room at a time. Every shot lands, nothing is random, and you can rewind as many turns as you like. From Suspicious Developments, the studio behind Gunpoint.
puzzlestrategynarrative-puzzleThere Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
A meta point-and-click in which a narrator insists there is no game while you drag and click the furniture of the game itself — title screen, menus, cursor. Each chapter jumps into a parody of a different genre. Made by Draw Me A Pixel.
puzzlemeta-puzzlenarrative-puzzleHappy Game
A point-and-click adventure that walks a sleeping boy through three chapters of nightmare. You pull, turn and pick at the screen to open the way forward, and what waits there is smiley faces, pink bunnies and rooms the colour of blood. Amanita Design's first turn toward horror, scored by the Czech band DVA.
puzzlepoint-and-clickadventureOneShot
A top-down puzzle adventure: guide a child through a world whose sun has died, carrying a single lightbulb toward the top of it. Between the item-combining, a handful of puzzles reach out into the player's own computer. From Future Cat.
puzzlemeta-puzzlenarrative-puzzleZero Escape: The Nonary Games
Two Spike Chunsoft mystery adventures in one package: nine people are locked inside a facility and must pass through numbered doors to get out. It bundles the DS-born Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors with its sequel Virtue's Last Reward, alternating first-person escape-room sections with branching novel sections.
mysteryadventurenarrative-puzzlePhoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy
A courtroom adventure in which you play defense attorney Phoenix Wright, matching one line of testimony against one piece of evidence to break a lie. Capcom's collection gathers all fourteen episodes of the three games first released between 2001 and 2004, with the art redrawn frame by frame.
mysteryvisual-noveldeductionThe Talos Principle: Reawakened
A first-person puzzle game through ruined gardens, where a jammer that shuts devices off, a connector that carries a beam and a recorder that replays your own movement combine to open doors. Croteam rebuilt their 2014 game in Unreal Engine 5 and packed the Road to Gehenna expansion, an eighteen-room new chapter and a level editor into one release.
puzzlefirst-personlogic-gridThe Bookwalker: Thief of Tales
A novelist whose ability to write has been shackled dives into books to steal the legendary objects inside them. Reality plays out in first person and the books in isometric view; you craft tools from scavenged junk and spend ink to rewrite a line of the story. A story-led point-and-click across seven fictional worlds, from DO MY BEST, the studio behind The Final Station.
narrative-puzzlepoint-and-clickadventureInscryption
A deckbuilding card game played across a candlelit table from Leshy, a narrator holed up in a cabin: you draw woodland-creature cards and sacrifice your own pieces to put them into play. Stand up from the table and the cabin itself becomes an escape-room puzzle. By Daniel Mullins, who made Pony Island.
puzzlemeta-puzzleescape-roomAI: The Somnium Files
A detective adventure set in near-future Tokyo, in which a one-eyed police detective works a serial murder case alongside the artificial intelligence housed in his prosthetic eye. First-person investigation scenes alternate with third-person 'Somnium' dives into a suspect's dream, where a six-minute budget must be spent to open Mental Locks, and an in-game flowchart lets you walk the branches toward several endings. Written and directed by Kotaro Uchikoshi of the Zero Escape series, from Spike Chunsoft.
mysteryadventurenarrative-puzzleSherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments
A third-person detective adventure set in Victorian London: walk the scene, lift clues from it, then wire them together on a board called the Deduction Space until a conclusion forms. Each of six standalone cases supports several conclusions, and you also decide whether to hand the person you name to the law or let them go. Made by Frogwares.
deductioninvestigationnarrative-puzzleSyberia: The World Before
A third-person adventure in which lawyer Kate Walker moves between two timelines — a girl named Dana in the 1930s and Kate's own present — retracing the history of the city of Vaghen alongside the automaton Oscar. Progress comes through assembling mechanisms and hint-assisted exploration. Microids' fourth entry in the series.
narrative-puzzleadventurepoint-and-clickPony Island
A meta-puzzle in which you are trapped in a deliberately shoddy arcade cabinet built by the devil, alternating between a pony side-scroller and puzzles that reorder instruction blocks inside the machine itself. Daniel Mullins's first commercial release turns the window and the UI into the mechanism.
puzzlemeta-puzzlenarrative-puzzleSyberia 3
A third-person adventure in which the lawyer Kate Walker joins a Youkol migration north, assembling clockwork devices along the way. Microïds' third Syberia, which trades the fixed painted screens of the first two games for a 3D space you walk around in.
narrative-puzzleadventurepoint-and-clickOrwell: Keeping an Eye On You
An adventure in which you operate a state surveillance system, assembling citizen profiles from fragments lifted out of social posts, news articles, private messages and tapped calls, and deciding who gets flagged. Osmotic Studios' five-episode surveillance drama, where submitting or withholding a fragment is your only move.
observationnarrative-puzzlesimulationScene Investigators
A first-person deduction game: walk reconstructed crime scenes, work out what happened from the evidence alone, and type your answers into an exam terminal. No hints, no confirmation. From EQ Studios, makers of The Painscreek Killings, built on their stated 70/30 principle.
deductionobservationinvestigationThe Vanishing of Ethan Carter
A first-person mystery in which you play an occult detective, walking a deserted valley to examine bodies and belongings and reassemble each death by putting the scattered fragments back in order — a photogrammetry-built forest explored with no map and no HUD, from The Astronauts.
investigationobservationnarrative-puzzleCryptmaster
A word-driven dungeon crawl in first person: type the words you have recovered to fire skills and answer riddles. Built in monochrome pencil illustration with a fully voiced narrator, by Paul Hart and Lee Williams.
puzzleword-gamenarrative-puzzleLittle Inferno
A 2D point-and-click that plays out entirely in front of a fireplace: order toys from a catalogue, burn them, watch how each one goes, and pair two or three of them by wordplay to find 99 "combos." Released in 2012 by Tomorrow Corporation, the studio behind World of Goo.
puzzlepoint-and-clicknarrative-puzzleDuck Detective: The Secret Salami
A 2.5D observation-and-deduction adventure where a down-on-his-luck duck detective peers at evidence and slots words into fill-in-the-blank sentences to crack the case of a stolen lunch. Happy Broccoli Games takes the Golden Idol style and makes it light, fully voiced, and pun-heavy.
deductionobservationnarrative-puzzleLucifer Within Us
An isometric detective game where you scrub testimony timelines and jab at contradictions to solve murders, piecing together motive, means, and opportunity in a daemon-haunted theocracy — from Kitfox Games.
mysteryobservationnarrative-puzzleArranger
A grid puzzle-adventure where taking one step moves everything sharing your row or column, and the board loops at its edges. No sword or keys — you shove the things on the floor to open the way. The debut from Furniture & Mattress, folding movement, combat, and exploration into a single verb.
puzzlegrid-basednarrative-puzzleThe Painscreek Killings
A first-person detective game in which you play a journalist combing the abandoned town of Painscreek — hunting keys, notes and diaries to solve a cold murder case. No quest markers, no hint system; your own notebook is the only tool. Made and published in 2017 by EQ Studios.
investigationobservationnarrative-puzzleTelling Lies
An FMV mystery where you search a database of secretly recorded video by the words spoken in it, reassembling four lives and one big lie from fragments. From Sam Barlow of Her Story, built on a single verb — search — that takes stories apart and rebuilds them.
narrative-puzzleobservationmysteryThe Rise of the Golden Idol
A 2D deduction adventure where you click through frozen crime scenes and drop harvested words into blanks to reconstruct who did what, why, and in what order. A standalone sequel to The Case of the Golden Idol, set across twenty linked cases in the 1970s.
deductionobservationnarrative-puzzleThe Roottrees are Dead
A first-person deduction puzzle: scour the early, dial-up-era Internet plus books and articles to establish who is truly blood-related to a crashed dynasty, filling in the blanks of their family tree. Evil Trout Inc.'s reworking of a free Global Game Jam browser game.
deductionobservationnarrative-puzzleThe Entropy Centre
A first-person puzzler in which you rewind an object's last 38 seconds with ASTRA, an AI companion gun, carrying and placing cubes to clear test chambers in a ruined orbital station. Stubby Games' debut, built around one verb: define the end state, then reverse-engineer the cause.
first-personpuzzlephysicsVoid Stranger
A 2D Sokoban puzzler in which you lift a floor tile with a rod and set it down elsewhere, descending a forgotten labyrinth past traps and foes. From a handful of verbs grow bottomless puzzles and a hidden story — made by System Erasure.
puzzlesokoban-likemeta-puzzleThe Spectrum Retreat
A first-person puzzler set in the art-deco Penrose Hotel: you pull a colour out of one wall, carry it, and hand it to a matching barrier to open the way. Steam sits at 'Mostly Positive,' 76% of 223 (snapshot 2026-06-16); opinion splits over its double structure of puzzle and story.
puzzlefirst-personnarrative-puzzleFilament
A puzzle game where you steer a small probe to wrap a single trailing cable around pillars, solving each room of an abandoned spaceship with one unbroken, non-crossing line.
puzzlelogicnarrative-puzzleThe Turing Test
A first-person sci-fi puzzle on a moon of Jupiter: redirect energy orbs between sockets to open doors and cross a series of test chambers, wrapped in a story about machine and human judgment.
puzzlefirst-personnarrative-puzzleThe Case of the Golden Idol
A deduction game: examine frozen crime-scene tableaus, gather words from the evidence, and fill in the blanks to reconstruct each murder across an 18th-century mystery.
deductionobservationnarrative-puzzleMaquette
A first-person recursive puzzle set in a world nested inside itself: the model at its center is the very world you stand in, so shrinking or enlarging objects ripples across scales — all wrapped in a love story.
perspective-puzzlenarrative-puzzlerecursionChants of Sennaar
Climbing a Babel-like tower, you decipher the unknown logographic language of each floor's people from pictures and gestures. A game of observation and inference.
observationnarrative-puzzlemeta-puzzleBlue Prince
A mansion roguelite where each day you draft the room behind the door.
logic-gridpathfindingmeta-puzzleLorelei and the Laser Eyes
In an eerie monochrome hotel, over 150 ciphers, numbers, and symbol puzzles weave through every floor.
logic-gridobservationnarrative-puzzleThe Talos Principle 2
Lasers and cubes and philosophical dialogue weigh equally in this first-person puzzle.
logic-gridnarrative-puzzleassemblyCOCOON
A world inside an orb, an orb inside that world, all the way down.
meta-puzzlenarrative-puzzleassemblyUnpacking
Pull things from boxes and place them on shelves. A 'life-told-by-objects' puzzle.
assemblynarrative-puzzleobservationOuter Wilds
Explore a solar system on a 22-minute loop and unravel the mysteries of an ancient race.
narrative-puzzleobservationmeta-puzzleReturn of the Obra Dinn
A monochrome mystery where an insurance assessor must identify sixty crew and reconstruct their fates aboard a ghost ship.
logic-gridobservationnarrative-puzzleGorogoa
A hand-drawn 2×2 grid of paintings. Rearrange, zoom, connect — a picture-book puzzle.
observationassemblynarrative-puzzleThe Witness
More than five hundred line-drawing panels. Observation itself becomes the verb.
observationnarrative-puzzlepathfindingHer Story
Search a police database of live-action video clips to reconstruct the story of a missing husband. An FMV mystery.
narrative-puzzleobservationmeta-puzzleThe Talos Principle
A robot solves trials in Roman-style ruins while a voice in their head questions their selfhood and divinity.
logic-gridpathfindingnarrative-puzzlePapers, Please
A border inspector in a fictional authoritarian state, caught between paperwork and morality.
logic-gridobservationnarrative-puzzleLIMBO
A boy walks through a monochrome forest searching for his sister. Trial and death advance the way.
physicsobservationnarrative-puzzleMachinarium
In a town built of scrap, a small robot rescues his lover. A hand-drawn, dialogue-free adventure.
narrative-puzzleassemblyobservationHalf-Life 2: Episode One
A five-hour escape with Alyx, blending gravity-gun physics puzzles and FPS combat.
physicsnarrative-puzzlePsychonauts
Dive into other characters' minds and solve the puzzles their inner worlds present. A peculiar 3D adventure.
narrative-puzzleobservationassemblySyberia II
Kate and the automaton Oscar travel into frozen Russia for one final leg of the journey.
narrative-puzzleassemblyobservationSyberia
Lawyer Kate Walker crosses Europe and Russia, unraveling the mystery of the automata.
narrative-puzzleassemblyobservationMyst III: Exile
A canonical Myst sequel across six Ages. The first to introduce 360-degree free view.
logic-gridobservationnarrative-puzzleEscape from Monkey Island
Pirate Guybrush's last classic, the era of 3D LucasArts adventure, with wildly inventive item combinations.
narrative-puzzleassemblyobservation
